I've been playing a lot with eToro in the last months, mainly with the very innovative OpenBook and CopyTrader platforms. The whole system is getting better and better, release after release. But still, in my experience, one serious bug is blocking eToro from being profitable for me. Here its is.
You know you already met this bug if you've already seen the error "trade no longer copying original trade due to unsufficient funds needed for new stop loss".
This bug can happen in two different situations: when you copy a single trade from a Guru, or when you copy full activity of a guru using CopyTrader. I will take the first situation, as it is the simplest one to get things clear.
Let's say I copy a single trade from a guru, investing 100$ on this trade. Is is a "BUY EUR/USD" trade, with a Stop Loss (SL) at -100% and a Take Profit (TP) at +100%. I can either loose the 100$, or earn 100$ plus my initial 100$. The point is that by investing 100$ in this trade, I trust eToro that I cannot loose more than 100$. This is a vital point.
For this example, let's say that the guru did in fact invest 1000$ on this exact same trade.
Let's say EUR/USD goes down a lot, and that we're almost hitting -100% (SL). The guru is confident that EUR/USD will goes up again, thus chooses to add 1000$ to his trade (total amount of the trade is 2000$ for him), and lowers the SL. Indeed, a few minutes later, EUR/USD goes up, and eventually hits the TP. The guru gets back his 2000$, plus a profit of 1000$.
What happened to your copied trade? Well, you would expect that eToro replicated everything for you. After all, it's what CopyTrader is all about.
So, you would expect that eToro made you add 100$ to your trade (total amount invested 200$), then after hitting TP, you would get back your 200$ plus a profit of 100$, just like your guru did. But no!
When you invested 100$ on the trade, eToro considers you want to risk 100$ and no more. Thus, it will never add for you more money on a trade, even if the guru behind the trade does it. So what will happen for you? Your trade will hit the original SL, and you will lose your 100$.
Here we are. You lost 100% of your investment, but your guru made a profit of 100% of initial investment. That's the bug.
Is this bug happening a lot? For me, yes, definitely! When I use CopyTrader to copy what popular guru do, I make some profits, but regularly this bug happens again and again, eating all my profits and more, and at the end I just lose money.
With this bug, CopyTrader can't be profitable, that's my opinion.
So now, what could we do? Is there any solution? I can see several :
- Solution number 1 : Guru should not be allowed to add any funds to a trade after it is started. It is a very radical solution, and would be very unpopular among gurus I guess, but still, this way, we can ensure CopyTrader really does what it's supposed to do.
- Solution number 2 : eToro adds funds to your copied trades when guru adds funds. There is a big drawback: when you invest 100$ on a single trade, if the guru adds more funds later, you can actually loose (much) more than the initial 100$!
- Solution number 3 : offer every user the option to enable "solution 2" in their settings. They should first fully understand the (high!) risks involved.
So you see, it's a complex bug, and there's no simple solution.
What do you think? Feel free to comment this post :-) Do you agree this is *the* bug of eToro?
Vermeer
